Gray 91-93 center panel help!

back, black, center, turn, make, gray, stays, paint, grey, hour, section, 91-93, panel, tail, lights, plastic, stuff, turning

So on my 91 mr2 the center section between the tail lights is turning gray. I have been using some plastic stuff that says will make it turn back to black, but it only stays black for a hour then goes back to grey. What should I use to make it turn back to black with out having to paint it. Thanks for the help